"Am I Overreacting" Fanfiction character edition!

Well, AO3 is a bit slow right now, and it's been a while since I've seen this kind of game being posted so how about we have some fun?

The rules are simple; make a comment that sounds like a post from r/AmIOverreacting. The key is to make it from the perspective of a character from your latest fanfic and have them ask if they're overreacting to something that happened within the story. And people can tell your character if they are overreacting or not or ask for more information.

I'll start:

I (F17) and my BF (M17) have a detective group at school. Today a new member (17[?] F) joined the group. She is pretty passable looking and smart-ish. The thing is, she, despite meeting my BF a few days ago, seems to be able to guess what he's thinking and planning. And it seems to go both ways... He can't do that with me this easily. And I've known my BF for over ten years, despite only starting to date recently.

Am I overreacting that someone he's just met is able to fall in synch so easily with him? Or is it normal that I'm feeling jealous? (And maybe want to punch the new girl's smug face)

Anyway, hope you guys have fun! :)

PS: Marked NSFW just in case.